{ "document_id": "fresh-arxiv-1599072", "source_sha256": "69607792a05b1ebb4f5f0a55c42fde76ec004efcb944fc6e10c5af5623ddd3e8", "kind": "ku", "status": "generated", "result": { "schema_version": "1.0", "title": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "abstract_sha256": "", "mode": "sequential", "model": "trained", "config": { "mode": "sequential", "chunk_words": 1000, "context_words": 0, "previous_units": 10, "canonicalize": false, "minhash_permutations": 16, "canonicalization_max_tokens": 4096, "parse_retries": 0 }, "knowledge_units": [ { "chunk_index": 0, "context_summary": "The paper analyzes a two-mass-two-spring model to explain 'fine structure' in atomic stick-slip motion observed in Friction Force Microscopy. It demonstrates that an ultra-low effective tip mass leads to contact delocalization, where the tip apex moves rapidly between surface potential wells. This model provides a theoretical basis for recent experimental findings that were previously attributed to improbable multi-tip contact configurations.", "entities": [ { "name": "two-mass-two-spring model", "entity_id": "two_mass_two_spring_model", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "components": "one real mass (M) for cantilever+tip inertia, one effective mass (m) for tip bending motion", "mass_ratio": "M is about 9 to 12 times larger than m. ", "effective_mass_m_estimate": "10^-20 kg", "computational_approach": "hybrid scheme combining numerical Langevin description and Monte-Carlo treatment" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "predicts", "target": "fine structure in atomic stick-slip motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "explains", "target": "recent puzzling experiments in FFM", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "demonstrates", "target": "contact delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Friction Force Microscopy (FFM)", "entity_id": "friction_force_microscopy_ffm", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "tool_status": "essential tool for nanotribology", "sensitivity": "nN or pN", "mechanism": "atomically sharp tip dragged by external spring (cantilever) along a surface" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "models", "target": "behavior of a single asperity", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "records", "target": "lateral force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "contact delocalization", "entity_id": "contact_delocalization", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "mechanism": "rapid, thermally activated motion of tip apex between surface potential wells", "condition": "effective mass m is low enough that jump rate is high relative to cantilever-tip characteristic frequency" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "causes", "target": "fine structure in slip events", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "sheds_light_on", "target": "asperities in macroscopic sliding bodies", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "fine structure in slip events", "entity_id": "fine_structure_in_slip_events", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "description": "nontrivial and physically rich features in atomic stick-slip motion", "experimental_status": "recently observed in typical systems with hard cantilevers" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "reflects", "target": "delocalization of tip-surface contact", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "previously_attributed_to", "target": "simultaneous contact via several nanotips", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Tomlinson model", "entity_id": "tomlinson_model", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "description": "single-spring model", "components": "effective mass close to cantilever mass dragged by effective spring accounting for cantilever and tip flexibility" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "traditionally_describes", "target": "FFM", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "fails_in", "target": "recent experiments showing fine structure", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "D Abel", "entity_id": "d_abel", "entity_type": "person", "aliases": [], "attributes": {}, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "authored", "target": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "S Yu Krylov", "entity_id": "s_yu_krylov", "entity_type": "person", "aliases": [], "attributes": {}, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "authored", "target": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "J W M Frenken", "entity_id": "j_w_m_frenken", "entity_type": "person", "aliases": [], "attributes": {}, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "authored", "target": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 0, "start_word": 0, "end_word": 992, "word_count": 992, "sha256": "d85f1b8d899ab3618357658b50cbe132cc31b26c4ae2952d021385c4e26bc4fd", "sentence_minhash": [ 14279474218976588, 1306423125707224, 102643128469009747, 37498130448765965, 2812407903185919, 37671122015440682, 76197433036625096, 22384502142726101, 21579496338166870, 3380668174306445, 33732523426331811, 77272953743708039, 157018458019500101, 42163599542804245, 92317792821805150, 658790404649858 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [] }, { "chunk_index": 1, "context_summary": "The text describes a two-mass-two-spring model for atomic-scale friction where a light tip apex moves rapidly between surface potential wells, causing contact delocalization. The model simplifies the system to a single Langevin equation for the cantilever combined with a Monte-Carlo algorithm for tip apex jumps. This approach explains 'fine structure' in slip events as a result of the cantilever responding to the mean position of a delocalized tip apex.", "entities": [ { "name": "two-mass-two-spring model", "entity_id": "two_mass_two_spring_model", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "geometry": "one-dimensional", "components": "cantilever and tip apex", "tip_mass_condition": "m << M", "frequency_hierarchy": "nu_t >> nu_c" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "simplifies_to", "target": "single Langevin equation", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "uses_algorithm", "target": "Monte-Carlo algorithm", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "explains", "target": "contact delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "cantilever", "entity_id": "cantilever", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "coordinate": "X", "mass": "M", "stiffness": "K", "damping_coefficient": "eta", "characteristic_frequency": "nu_c", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "coupled_to", "target": "tip apex", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "moves_with", "target": "scanning velocity V", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "responds_to", "target": "mean tip apex position", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip apex", "entity_id": "tip_apex", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "coordinate": "x", "effective_mass": "m", "stiffness": "k", "characteristic_frequency": "nu_t", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "coupled_to", "target": "cantilever", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "interacts_with", "target": "surface potential", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "undergoes", "target": "thermally activated jumps", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "surface potential", "entity_id": "surface_potential", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "form": "sinusoidal", "amplitude": "U0", "period": "a", "equation": "Us = U0/2 * [1 - cos(2*pi*x/a)]" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "determines", "target": "local minima xi(X)", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Tomlinson parameter", "entity_id": "tomlinson_parameter", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "symbol": "gamma", "formula": "2*pi^2 * U0 * k * a^2", "threshold_for_multiple_wells": "gamma > 1" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "determines", "target": "number of wells", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "origin_of", "target": "stick-slip motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "jump rate", "entity_id": "jump_rate", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "symbol": "rij", "approximation": "transition state theory", "formula": "nu_t * exp(-Uij / kBT)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "depends_on", "target": "potential barrier Uij", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "governs", "target": "Monte-Carlo transitions", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "contact delocalization", "entity_id": "contact_delocalization", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "cause": "rapid jumps between wells", "condition": "jump rate exceeds nu_c" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "results_in", "target": "smoothened stochastic behavior of cantilever", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Langevin equation", "entity_id": "langevin_equation", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "equation": "M*X'' = -k[X - xi(X)] - K(X - Vt) - M*eta*X' + xi", "random_force_normalization": "xi(t)xi(t') = 2*M*eta*nkBT*delta(t-t')", "damping_condition": "eta = 5*nu_c", "noise_reduction_factor": "sqrt(10)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "describes", "target": "cantilever motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "experimental parameters", "entity_id": "experimental_parameters", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "m": "1e-20 kg", "a": "0.66 nm", "K": "62 N/m", "V": "25 nm/s", "T": "300 K", "M": "5.5e-11 kg", "k": "3 N/m" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "used_in", "target": "calculations", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 1, "start_word": 992, "end_word": 1981, "word_count": 989, "sha256": "236dd00edabdfce3ffb5fc72f5dce4ee647450a1e5c9d230e768a350f41c962d", "sentence_minhash": [ 82316180561614159, 1306423125707224, 4901304760856621, 61919449716151556, 99441767708229822, 62667647458868521, 164480005983286773, 1125529973969978, 19874090017850400, 3380668174306445, 67831053780325945, 7578552932006974, 11610845633202285, 14638101201935915, 37122965930226008, 117472307714712089 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'cantilever'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'tip apex'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 2, "context_summary": "The cantilever moves in an effective potential shaped by the rapid thermal motion of the tip apex, which can cause the mean surface force to exhibit discontinuities or reductions. The model predicts that slip events with intermediate states occur when the tip apex is delocalized between two wells, a phenomenon observed in experiments with very low effective tip masses. The study concludes that the actual effective mass of the contact is less than 10^-18 kg, and that the rapid motion of the tip apex in the GHz range is a key factor in energy dissipation.", "entities": [ { "name": "cantilever", "entity_id": "cantilever", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "motion_driver": "effective potential formed by rapid thermal motion of tip apex", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "moves_in", "target": "effective potential", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "exhibits_slip_via", "target": "intermediate state", "attributes": { "condition": "step-like change in mean surface force" }, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "effective potential", "entity_id": "effective_potential", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "formula": "U_eff(X) = X_0 F_s(X') dX'", "feature": "flattened at top or has shallow minimum in two-well interval" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "formed_by", "target": "rapid thermal motion of tip apex", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "influenced_by", "target": "competition between potential energy increase and entropy increase", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip apex", "entity_id": "tip_apex", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "motion_type": "rapid thermal motion", "mean_position_formula": "x(X) = x_1 p_1 + x_2 p_2", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "determines", "target": "mean surface force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "delocalized_in", "target": "two-well interval", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "mean surface force", "entity_id": "mean_surface_force", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "formula": "F_s(X) = -k(X - x)", "behavior": "exhibits discontinuities at sudden transitions of tip apex potential" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "reduced_in", "target": "two-well interval", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "caused_by", "target": "rapid oscillations of instantaneous force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "intermediate state", "entity_id": "intermediate_state", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "characteristic": "nearly zero mean surface force", "relation_to_mass": "disappears if effective mass m exceeds 10^-18 kg", "model_entity_type": "phenomenon" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "reflects", "target": "complete delocalization of contact", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "observed_in", "target": "slip events with step-like change", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "effective mass of contact", "entity_id": "effective_mass_of_contact", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "upper_estimate": "< 10^-18 kg", "evidence": "occurrence of slips with intermediate state" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "contrasts", "target": "earlier expectations", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "agrees_with", "target": "recent calculations", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "surface corrugation", "entity_id": "surface_corrugation", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "actual_shape": "wider barriers and narrower wells", "model_assumption": "simple sinusoidal potential" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "causes_discrepancy_in", "target": "slip durations", "attributes": { "direction": "experimental durations are larger than simulated" }, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "increases", "target": "maximum lateral force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "energy dissipation", "entity_id": "energy_dissipation", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "key_element": "rapid motion of tip apex", "characteristic_frequency": "GHz range" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "depends_on", "target": "friction regime", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 2, "start_word": 1981, "end_word": 2971, "word_count": 990, "sha256": "6524ccf6bbb179c5d0bc146c31a8e44bed8ac0c36e095569cedd9a034eb6eafb", "sentence_minhash": [ 181103902342795345, 1306423125707224, 6687337363432560, 89647839879950313, 72424486488803959, 62667647458868521, 23718652799488495, 50347065011191293, 25627064558161218, 92715222163426349, 67831053780325945, 30828592349773787, 51125582506972287, 906306679132868, 92317792821805150, 117472307714712089 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'cantilever'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'tip apex'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'phenomenon' for 'intermediate state'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 3, "context_summary": "The text identifies two mechanisms for energy relaxation in the tip-substrate system: intratip vibration damping and apex motion damping. It suggests that contact delocalization effects may extend to macroscopic sliding dynamics. Specific simulation parameters and examples of slip events are provided for various surface corrugations.", "entities": [ { "name": "energy relaxation mechanisms", "entity_id": "energy_relaxation_mechanisms", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "mechanism_1": "damping of intratip vibrations", "mechanism_2": "damping of apex motion with respect to substrate", "status": "relative importance unresolved" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "produces", "target": "phonons inside the tip", "attributes": { "associated_with": "mechanism_1" }, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "produces", "target": "phonons in the substrate and tip", "attributes": { "associated_with": "mechanism_2" }, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "macroscopic sliding", "entity_id": "macroscopic_sliding", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "potential_dynamics": "thermally driven", "cause": "local compliance of contacting surfaces" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "influenced_by", "target": "contact delocalization effects", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "surface corrugation examples", "entity_id": "surface_corrugation_examples", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "atomic_stick_slip_range": "high and moderate", "continuous_sliding_range": "low", "values": "U0 = 1.2, 0.48, 0.3 eV" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "slip event examples", "entity_id": "slip_event_examples", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "corrugation_values": "1.2, 1.0, 0.9, 0.7, 0.52, 0.48, 0.43, 0.42 eV" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "simulation parameters", "entity_id": "simulation_parameters", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "effective_mass_m": "10^-20 kg", "source": "Ref. [9]" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "thermal noise", "entity_id": "thermal_noise", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "value": "ηn = 0", "purpose": "visualize intermediate state accompanying contact delocalization" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "effective tip-surface interaction", "entity_id": "effective_tip_surface_interaction", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "corrugation_values": "0.52, 0.48, 0.44 eV" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "plotted_against", "target": "cantilever position", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "mean surface force", "entity_id": "mean_surface_force", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "corrugation_values": "0.52, 0.48, 0.44 eV" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "plotted_against", "target": "cantilever position", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 3, "start_word": 2971, "end_word": 3254, "word_count": 283, "sha256": "796bca4777472eaa29146bac106fc76c4a1f2d11129467ee1d9e80f185159464", "sentence_minhash": [ 181103902342795345, 18551641988871988, 61896554882702054, 159448631219318875, 50154285776315358, 62667647458868521, 175774020269814206, 418821805197748160, 64333332902950267, 92715222163426349, 59581572940983686, 356631250106938027, 164575269931903557, 14638101201935915, 423009623579688101, 91498461405850096 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [] } ], "canonical_entities": [] }, "chunks_expected": 4, "chunks_generated": 4, "failed_chunks": [], "repair": { "accepted_windows": 1, "rolled_back": false, "original_context_sha256": "2b05966d63d1f0c0df6f2825d13d2063462da5d37d93033adfcaf8904f04f994", "final_context_sha256": "13fb6025aede88c504ec7b3f4f140ecbb7b9c6d51ce5efdebb2fff69c79d4238", "critical_values": { "passed": true, "checks": { "numbers": true, "quantities": true, "formulas": true, "mathematical_variables": true, "operators": true }, "before": { "numbers": [ "9", "12", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "2", "1", "2", "2", "2", "2", "1", "2", "5", "1E+1", "1E-20", "0.66", "62", "25", "3E+2", "5.5E-11", "3", "1E+1", "-18", "1E+1", "-18", "1E+1", "-18", "1.2", "0.48", "0.3", "1.2", "1", "0.9", "0.7", "0.52", "0.48", "0.43", "0.42", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "0", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44" ], "quantities": [ [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "1E-20", "kg" ], [ "0.66", "nm" ], [ "62", "N/m" ], [ "25", "nm/s" ], [ "3E+2", "K" ], [ "5.5E-11", "kg" ], [ "3", "N/m" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "0.3", "eV" ], [ "0.42", "eV" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "0.44", "eV" ], [ "0.44", "eV" ] ], "formulas": [ "0=1.2", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "2*M", "K(X-Vt)", "M*X", "N/m", "N/m", "X-x", "a=5", "a>1", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "cos(2*pi*x/a)", "exp(-Uij/kBT)", "k(X-x)", "k*a^2", "n=0", "p_1+x_2", "s=U", "sqrt(1E+1)", "t-t", "x(X)", "x/a" ], "mathematical_variables": [ "F_s", "F_s", "U_eff", "X_0", "c_frequency", "c_frequency", "c_frequency", "c_stick_slip_range", "d_against", "d_against", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_for_multiple_wells", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_to", "d_to", "d_with", "d_with", "e_mass", "e_mass_m", "e_mass_m_estimate", "e_reduction_factor", "g_coefficient", "g_condition", "l_approach", "l_assumption", "l_dynamics", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_shape", "l_status", "l_status", "m_1", "m_1", "m_2", "m_2", "m_force_normalization", "n_driver", "n_of", "n_position_formula", "n_to_mass", "n_type", "n_values", "n_values", "n_values", "p_1", "p_2", "p_mass_condition", "r_estimate", "s_algorithm", "s_discrepancy_in", "s_in", "s_in", "s_in", "s_light_on", "s_on", "s_on", "s_ratio", "s_sliding_range", "s_slip_via", "s_to", "s_to", "s_with", "s_with", "s_with", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "u_c", "u_c", "u_c", "u_c", "u_t", "u_t", "u_t", "x_1", "x_2", "y_attributed_to", "y_describes", "y_element", "y_hierarchy", "η" ], "operators": [ "<", "<", ">", ">", "=", ">", "=", "=", "=", "=", "=", "=", "<", "=", "=" ] }, "after": { "numbers": [ "9", "12", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "2", "1", "2", "2", "2", "2", "1", "2", "5", "1E+1", "1E-20", "0.66", "62", "25", "3E+2", "5.5E-11", "3", "1E+1", "-18", "1E+1", "-18", "1E+1", "-18", "1.2", "0.48", "0.3", "1.2", "1", "0.9", "0.7", "0.52", "0.48", "0.43", "0.42", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "0", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44" ], "quantities": [ [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "1E-20", "kg" ], [ "0.66", "nm" ], [ "62", "N/m" ], [ "25", "nm/s" ], [ "3E+2", "K" ], [ "5.5E-11", "kg" ], [ "3", "N/m" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "0.3", "eV" ], [ "0.42", "eV" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "0.44", "eV" ], [ "0.44", "eV" ] ], "formulas": [ "0=1.2", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "2*M", "K(X-Vt)", "M*X", "N/m", "N/m", "X-x", "a=5", "a>1", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "cos(2*pi*x/a)", "exp(-Uij/kBT)", "k(X-x)", "k*a^2", "n=0", "p_1+x_2", "s=U", "sqrt(1E+1)", "t-t", "x(X)", "x/a" ], "mathematical_variables": [ "F_s", "F_s", "U_eff", "X_0", "c_frequency", "c_frequency", "c_frequency", "c_stick_slip_range", "d_against", "d_against", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_for_multiple_wells", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_to", "d_to", "d_with", "d_with", "e_mass", "e_mass_m", "e_mass_m_estimate", "e_reduction_factor", "g_coefficient", "g_condition", "l_approach", "l_assumption", "l_dynamics", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_shape", "l_status", "l_status", "m_1", "m_1", "m_2", "m_2", "m_force_normalization", "n_driver", "n_of", "n_position_formula", "n_to_mass", "n_type", "n_values", "n_values", "n_values", "p_1", "p_2", "p_mass_condition", "r_estimate", "s_algorithm", "s_discrepancy_in", "s_in", "s_in", "s_in", "s_light_on", "s_on", "s_on", "s_ratio", "s_sliding_range", "s_slip_via", "s_to", "s_to", "s_with", "s_with", "s_with", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "u_c", "u_c", "u_c", "u_c", "u_t", "u_t", "u_t", "x_1", "x_2", "y_attributed_to", "y_describes", "y_element", "y_hierarchy", "η" ], "operators": [ "<", "<", ">", ">", "=", ">", "=", "=", "=", "=", "=", "=", "<", "=", "=" ] }, "numeric_content_present": true, "formula_content_present": true, "exact_text_unchanged": false, "interpretation": "Conservative preservation filter; changed signatures require review and can include harmless reordering or equivalent unit/algebra conversions" } }, "condition": "gemma12_r128_ku1000_bt", "source_metadata": { "title": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "authors": [ "D Abel", "S Yu Krylov", "J W M Frenken" ], "doi": "10.48550/arxiv.0707.3072", "year": "", "openalex_id": "https://openalex.org/W6966472410", "origin": "Existing disjoint 20-paper benchmark cohort", "metadata_added_for_attribution_only": true, "metadata_not_used_to_change_QA_context": true } }