{ "document_id": "fresh-arxiv-1599072", "source_sha256": "69607792a05b1ebb4f5f0a55c42fde76ec004efcb944fc6e10c5af5623ddd3e8", "kind": "ku", "status": "generated", "result": { "schema_version": "1.0", "title": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "abstract_sha256": "", "mode": "sequential", "model": "base", "config": { "mode": "sequential", "chunk_words": 500, "context_words": 0, "previous_units": 10, "canonicalize": false, "minhash_permutations": 16, "canonicalization_max_tokens": 4096, "parse_retries": 0 }, "knowledge_units": [ { "chunk_index": 0, "context_summary": "The study analyzes a two-spring model to explain fine structure in Friction Force Microscopy (FFM) data. It proposes that the tip apex can be delocalized due to rapid thermally activated motion. This model challenges the traditional Tomlinson model, which is based on a single spring, for atomic friction. ", "entities": [ { "name": "two-spring model", "entity_id": "two_spring_model", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "configuration": "two-mass-two-spring scheme", "mass_1": "real mass (M) accounting for combined cantilever+tip inertia", "mass_2": "effective mass (m) associated with bending motion of the tip", "condition_for_delocalization": "effective mass m is low enough for high rate of thermally activated jumps relative to cantilever-tip motion frequency" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "predicts", "target": "fine structure in atomic stick-slip motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "explains", "target": "contact delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "supersedes", "target": "single-spring (Tomlinson) model", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Friction Force Microscopy (FFM)", "entity_id": "friction_force_microscopy_ffm", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "function": "nanotribology tool", "mechanism": "atomically sharp tip dragged along surface by external spring (cantilever)", "sensitivity": "nN or pN lateral force recording", "typical_observation": "periodic stick-slip behavior with substrate lattice period" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "models", "target": "single asperity behavior", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "provides_access_to", "target": "origin of friction at atomic scale", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "single-spring (Tomlinson) model", "entity_id": "single_spring_tomlinson_model", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "description": "effective mass close to cantilever dragged by effective spring accounting for cantilever and tip flexibility", "status": "traditionally used but recently shown to fail in some cases" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "describes", "target": "FFM stick-slip physics", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "contact delocalization", "entity_id": "contact_delocalization", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "definition": "tip apex is completely or partially delocalized", "mechanism": "Rapid, thermally-induced movement of the surface tip between surface potentials ", "condition": "occurs when effective mass m is ultra-low" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "observed_in", "target": "recent puzzling FFM experiments", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "indicated_by", "target": "fine structure in atomic stick-slip motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "FFM tip", "entity_id": "ffm_tip", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "rigidity": "softer than most cantilevers", "function": "models single asperity", "model_entity_type": "object" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "part_of", "target": "Friction Force Microscopy (FFM)", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 0, "start_word": 0, "end_word": 500, "word_count": 500, "sha256": "006187bfb8e6e4f27a06092b540426e60024d680c3ffdb8c45e56ccafa46161f", "sentence_minhash": [ 138742571471211904, 132024682887321555, 259197737023610255, 37498130448765965, 42052357859457007, 234874774536143700, 149017575652778032, 22384502142726101, 193468123599729578, 107048872566759164, 78280491562202942, 77272953743708039, 157018458019500101, 132529644835130180, 303264414993015767, 658790404649858 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'object' for 'FFM tip'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 1, "context_summary": "The study presents a theoretical analysis of a two-mass-two-spring system to explain fine structure in slip events observed in Friction Force Microscopy (FFM). It proposes that the tip apex mass is ultra-low, leading to contact delocalization that affects the measured friction dynamics. A hybrid computational method combining Langevin and Monte-Carlo simulations was used to model the interplay between the fast tip motion and slow cantilever response.", "entities": [ { "name": "two-mass-two-spring system", "entity_id": "two_mass_two_spring_system", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "mass_ratio": "m << M", "tip_mass_estimate": "10^-20 kg", "cantilever_mass_range": "9 to 12 orders of magnitude higher than tip mass", "model_entity_type": "model" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "describes", "target": "dynamics of atomic scale friction", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "explains", "target": "fine structure of slip events", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "hybrid computational scheme", "entity_id": "hybrid_computational_scheme", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "components": [ "numerical Langevin description of cantilever+tip motion", "Monte-Carlo treatment of thermally activated motion of tip's apex" ] }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "enables_tracking_of", "target": "dynamic interplay between rapid motion of m and slow motion of M", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "reveals", "target": "variety of dynamic behavior", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "contact delocalization", "entity_id": "contact_delocalization", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "state": "completely or partially delocalized", "cause": "ultra-low effective mass m" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "reflected_in", "target": "unusual slip events with nontrivial fine structure", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "challenges", "target": "explanation of simultaneous contact via several nanotips", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "FFM slip events", "entity_id": "ffm_slip_events", "entity_type": "event", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "types": [ "fast slipping", "slip events with nontrivial fine structure" ], "dependence": "sensitive to surface corrugation" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "observed_in", "target": "high-resolution experiment [9]", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "dissipates", "target": "energy stored in the system", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "high-resolution experiment [9]", "entity_id": "high_resolution_experiment_9", "entity_type": "event", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "capability": "resolved durations of slip events", "system_type": "hard cantilever" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "confirmed", "target": "theoretical results on delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "previously_attributed_fine_structure_to", "target": "simultaneous contact via several nanotips", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 1, "start_word": 500, "end_word": 992, "word_count": 492, "sha256": "fcc193ed6c49d818ce71582b549922761820fff155851f07e4fa22a3df38a51c", "sentence_minhash": [ 14279474218976588, 1306423125707224, 102643128469009747, 89647839879950313, 2812407903185919, 37671122015440682, 76197433036625096, 50347065011191293, 21579496338166870, 3380668174306445, 33732523426331811, 135913608210607781, 164575269931903557, 42163599542804245, 92317792821805150, 117472307714712089 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'model' for 'two-mass-two-spring system'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 2, "context_summary": "The text defines the mathematical model for a one-dimensional two-mass system, specifying the potential energy and equations of motion for the cantilever and tip apex. It introduces the Tomlinson parameter to determine the number of potential wells and the conditions for thermally activated jumps. A hybrid numerical method combining a Langevin equation for the cantilever and a Monte-Carlo algorithm for tip transitions is described, including the treatment of damping and noise.", "entities": [ { "name": "one-dimensional system potential energy", "entity_id": "one_dimensional_system_potential_energy", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "geometry": "one-dimensional", "components": "cantilever coordinate X, tip apex coordinate x, support position Vt, cantilever stiffness K, tip stiffness k" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "includes_interaction", "target": "tip-surface interaction", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip-surface interaction", "entity_id": "tip_surface_interaction", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "form": "sinusoidal", "amplitude": "U0", "period": "a", "formula": "Us = U0/2 [1 - cos(2πx/a)]" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "two coupled equations of motion", "entity_id": "two_coupled_equations_of_motion", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "description": "Describes cantilever+tip combination (mass M, position X) and tip apex (effective mass m, position x relative to X)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "simplified_by", "target": "averaging over rapid thermal motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Tomlinson parameter", "entity_id": "tomlinson_parameter", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "symbol": "γ", "formula": "2π²U0/(ka²)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "determines", "target": "number of wells available to the apex", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "condition_for_multiple_wells", "target": "γ > 1", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "thermally activated jumps", "entity_id": "thermally_activated_jumps", "entity_type": "event", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "mechanism": "tip apex moving between potential wells", "origin": "stick-slip motion and multiple wells (γ > 1)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "modeled_by", "target": "transition state theory approximation", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "jump rate", "entity_id": "jump_rate", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "symbol": "rij", "formula": "νt exp(-Uij/kBT)", "Uij_definition": "potential barrier between wells i and j" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "hybrid numerical scheme", "entity_id": "hybrid_numerical_scheme", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "components": "single Langevin-type equation for cantilever, Monte-Carlo algorithm for tip apex transitions" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "solves", "target": "cantilever motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "handles", "target": "tip apex transitions between positions xi and xj", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Langevin equation for cantilever", "entity_id": "langevin_equation_for_cantilever", "entity_type": "method", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "equation": "M X'' = -k[X - xi(X)] - K(X - Vt) - M η X' + ξ", "random_force_normalization": "ξ(t)ξ(t') = 2M ηn kBT δ(t - t')" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "uses_damping_coefficient", "target": "ηn", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "fluctuation-dissipation theorem", "entity_id": "fluctuation_dissipation_theorem", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "application": "particle interacting with a bath" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "implies", "target": "ηn = η", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "cantilever damping", "entity_id": "cantilever_damping", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "coupling": "indirect via tip apex motion relative to cantilever and surface", "status": "neglected in reference [9]" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "controlled_by", "target": "varying η and ηn in calculations", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 2, "start_word": 992, "end_word": 1447, "word_count": 455, "sha256": "c188fe3ee3ae3bb56a1cb6e667987d7d78d393b724bf3acefa89088154037bbe", "sentence_minhash": [ 82316180561614159, 1306423125707224, 4901304760856621, 148613333131239159, 99441767708229822, 120624748091028973, 164480005983286773, 1125529973969978, 19874090017850400, 3380668174306445, 67831053780325945, 7578552932006974, 11610845633202285, 14638101201935915, 159289067325148646, 382712784620362330 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [] }, { "chunk_index": 3, "context_summary": "The study presents simulation results for a slightly overdamped two-mass system with reduced noise to visualize slip event fine structure. Specific physical parameters, including tip mass and stiffness, are derived from experimental data and best-fit analyses. The text describes how varying surface corrugation leads to distinct friction regimes, ranging from trivial stick-slip to near-dissipationless motion.", "entities": [ { "name": "slightly overdamped motion case", "entity_id": "slightly_overdamped_motion_case", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "damping_parameter": "η = 5νc", "noise_reduction_factor": "√10", "noise_parameter": "ηn = 0.5νc", "model_entity_type": "simulation_condition" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "purpose", "target": "better visualize fine structure of slip events", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "damping parameter range", "entity_id": "damping_parameter_range", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "lower_bound": "0.1νc", "upper_bound": "10νc", "model_entity_type": "parameter_range" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "qualitative_result_stability", "target": "results do not change qualitatively", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "fluctuation_behavior", "target": "stronger fluctuations at lower damping and higher random force amplitude", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip mass", "entity_id": "tip_mass", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "value": "1 • 10^-20 kg", "source": "estimated in [10]", "model_entity_type": "physical_parameter" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "experimental parameters from Ref. [9]", "entity_id": "experimental_parameters_from_ref_9", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "lattice_constant_a": "0.66 nm", "cantilever_stiffness_K": "62 N/m", "scan_velocity_V": "25 nm/s", "temperature_T": "300 K", "cantilever_mass_M": "5.5 • 10^-11 kg", "model_entity_type": "parameter_set" }, "relationships": [] }, { "name": "tip stiffness", "entity_id": "tip_stiffness", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "value": "3 N/m", "selection_method": "best fit to experimental stick-slip patterns at high corrugations", "typical_range": "several N/m", "model_entity_type": "physical_parameter" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "source_reference", "target": "Fig. 2-a of Ref. [9]", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "surface corrugation", "entity_id": "surface_corrugation", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "symbol": "U0", "experimental_equivalent": "changing scan lines", "model_entity_type": "experimental_variable" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "controls_regime_transition", "target": "friction regimes", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "high corrugation regime", "entity_id": "high_corrugation_regime", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "condition": "high U0", "jump_probability": "low", "model_entity_type": "friction_regime" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "characterized_by", "target": "stick-slip with trivial slips", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "mechanism", "target": "each tip slip followed by cantilever slip", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "cantilever_slip_timescale", "target": "ν^-1c", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "lower corrugation regime", "entity_id": "lower_corrugation_regime", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "condition": "somewhat lower U0", "jump_rate": "larger", "model_entity_type": "friction_regime" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "characterized_by", "target": "structured slips", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "apex_behavior", "target": "several additional jumps back and forth between wells", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "cantilever_behavior", "target": "exhibits smoothened stochastic behavior", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "cause_of_cantilever_behavior", "target": "cantilever cannot follow rapid jumps of tip apex", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "very low corrugation regime", "entity_id": "very_low_corrugation_regime", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "condition": "very low U0", "tomlinson_parameter_condition": "γ < 1", "model_entity_type": "friction_regime" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "characterized_by", "target": "near-dissipationless motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip apex potential landscape", "entity_id": "tip_apex_potential_landscape", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "tomlinson_parameter_status": "not too far from unity", "model_entity_type": "physical_state" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "double_well_condition", "target": "cantilever close to midway between lattice sites (X = a/2, 3a/2, ...)", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "single_well_condition", "target": "otherwise", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "barrier_height_comparison", "target": "potential barrier considerably lower than surface corrugation U0", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "jump_rate_consequence", "target": "rate of thermally activated jumps can be very high", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 3, "start_word": 1447, "end_word": 1922, "word_count": 475, "sha256": "9f05a20d8ad93fa1ad8bce5ec8916575070352077b028c28e64b6b59ba624506", "sentence_minhash": [ 82316180561614159, 232593725413697090, 110182565901905120, 61919449716151556, 99441767708229822, 62667647458868521, 164480005983286773, 41678443202000680, 228439795799410229, 67286569826781287, 78280491562202942, 142723333974471510, 91759520063933247, 14638101201935915, 37122965930226008, 117472307714712089 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'simulation_condition' for 'slightly overdamped motion case'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'parameter_range' for 'damping parameter range'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_parameter' for 'tip mass'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'parameter_set' for 'experimental parameters from Ref. [9]'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_parameter' for 'tip stiffness'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'experimental_variable' for 'surface corrugation'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_regime' for 'high corrugation regime'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_regime' for 'lower corrugation regime'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_regime' for 'very low corrugation regime'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_state' for 'tip apex potential landscape'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 4, "context_summary": "In the two-well regime, the tip apex delocalizes due to rapid thermal jumps, causing the cantilever to move in an effective potential defined by the mean tip position. The mean surface force is reduced and the effective potential is flattened due to the competition between increasing potential energy and entropy from apex disorder. Discontinuities in the mean force correspond to transitions between one-well and two-well potential shapes, occurring over a timescale determined by the jump rates.", "entities": [ { "name": "two-well regime", "entity_id": "two_well_regime", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "mean_jump_rate": "exceeds 0.5 * 10^9 Hz", "jump_rate_condition": "high above characteristic frequency nu_c of cantilever" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "causes", "target": "tip apex delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "characterized_by", "target": "rapid jumps between two accessible wells", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "effective potential", "entity_id": "effective_potential", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "definition": "U_eff(X) = integral of F_s(X') dX'", "formation_mechanism": "formed by rapid thermal motion of the tip apex" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "governs_motion_of", "target": "cantilever", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "flattened_at", "target": "top of surface corrugation", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "may_contain", "target": "shallow minimum", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "mean surface force", "entity_id": "mean_surface_force", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "formula": "F_s(X) = -k(X - x)", "behavior_in_two_well_interval": "essentially reduced", "discontinuity_cause": "transitions of tip apex potential from one-well to two-well shape" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "exhibits_discontinuities_at", "target": "positions of cantilever where potential shape changes", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "reduction_explained_by", "target": "rapid oscillations of instantaneous force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "reflects_gradual_change_in", "target": "gradual slip of tip", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip apex", "entity_id": "tip_apex", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "state_in_two_well_regime": "delocalized", "mean_position_formula": "x(X) = x_1 p_1 + x_2 p_2", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "jumps_between", "target": "two accessible wells", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "probabilities_determined_by", "target": "equilibrium distribution of apex positions", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "cantilever", "entity_id": "cantilever", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "perceived_motion": "moves in effective potential", "perceived_position": "sees only mean tip apex position", "model_entity_type": "component" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "exhibits_slip_via", "target": "intermediate state", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "slip_reflects", "target": "nearly zero mean surface force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "entropy", "entity_id": "entropy", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "change_in_two_well_regime": "This increases due to a disruption in the apex position. " }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "competes_with", "target": "increase in mean potential energy", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "contributes_to", "target": "flattening of effective potential", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 4, "start_word": 1922, "end_word": 2384, "word_count": 462, "sha256": "3d5d872561fa4c681ad071808e560309cf2e30e563f3305fe07e80f1dbb57b09", "sentence_minhash": [ 542989839357426248, 18551641988871988, 6687337363432560, 139282502133510779, 99441767708229822, 99436724310786061, 149017575652778032, 50347065011191293, 25627064558161218, 92715222163426349, 67831053780325945, 30828592349773787, 51125582506972287, 62445563022006556, 98254322503569589, 205893516960207536 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'tip apex'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'component' for 'cantilever'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 5, "context_summary": "The text validates the two-mass model against experimental data, noting that single slip events occur at both high and very low surface corrugations. It identifies a discrepancy in slip duration, attributing it to non-sinusoidal surface potentials with wider barriers. The analysis constrains the effective contact mass to less than 10^-18 kg based on the presence of intermediate slip states.", "entities": [ { "name": "single slips", "entity_id": "single_slips", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "definition": "Conditions where the cantilever exhibits a small number of jumps per lattice spacing", "occurrence_conditions": "High U0 or very low surface corrugations (gamma close to unity)", "model_entity_type": "friction_regime" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "caused_by", "target": "narrow interval of cantilever positions where apex sees two surface wells", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Ref. [9] observations", "entity_id": "ref_9_observations", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "status": "Recent observations confirming predictions", "model_entity_type": "experimental_data" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "reproduced_in", "target": "Fig. 3", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "matches", "target": "simulated fine structure in slip events", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "matches", "target": "simulated ranges of variation of lateral force", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "simulated slip durations", "entity_id": "simulated_slip_durations", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "comparison_to_experiment": "Smaller than experimental durations" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "discrepancy_attributed_to", "target": "non-sinusoidal surface corrugation", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "non-sinusoidal surface potential", "entity_id": "non_sinusoidal_surface_potential", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "characteristics": "Wider barriers and narrower wells", "effect_on_slip_duration": "Increased", "effect_on_lateral_force": "Increased maximum lateral force for same corrugation", "model_entity_type": "physical_model" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "previously_encountered_in", "target": "Ref. [14]", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "effective contact mass", "entity_id": "effective_contact_mass", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "upper_estimate": "< 10^-18 kg", "magnitude": "Very small", "model_entity_type": "physical_parameter" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "contradicts", "target": "earlier expectations [7, 9]", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "agrees_with", "target": "recent calculations [10]", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "evidenced_by", "target": "occurrence of slips with intermediate state", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "slips with intermediate state", "entity_id": "slips_with_intermediate_state", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "significance": "Most specific slips directly related to complete delocalization of contact", "sensitivity_to_mass": "Less pronounced and shorter if mass increased by two orders of magnitude; absent if increased by three orders of magnitude", "model_entity_type": "friction_event" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "observed_in", "target": "Figs. 1-i and 3-d", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "stuck-in-slipperiness", "entity_id": "stuck_in_slipperiness", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "predicted_in": "Ref. [10]", "system_condition": "Soft cantilever", "model_entity_type": "friction_regime" }, "relationships": [] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 5, "start_word": 2384, "end_word": 2866, "word_count": 482, "sha256": "c56e239be856df14ed7561630fa704c51bca57bdfb6aa8ce53c76f9799ca4d2e", "sentence_minhash": [ 181103902342795345, 1306423125707224, 152402704048383776, 89647839879950313, 72424486488803959, 62667647458868521, 23718652799488495, 65918950900603172, 96635883400075078, 92715222163426349, 78280491562202942, 142723333974471510, 157018458019500101, 906306679132868, 92317792821805150, 117472307714712089 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_regime' for 'single slips'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'experimental_data' for 'Ref. [9] observations'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_model' for 'non-sinusoidal surface potential'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_parameter' for 'effective contact mass'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_event' for 'slips with intermediate state'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'friction_regime' for 'stuck-in-slipperiness'" ] }, { "chunk_index": 6, "context_summary": "The text discusses how contact delocalization can occur at any cantilever position in specific regimes, necessitating a re-evaluation of standard Friction Force Microscopy (FFM) interpretations. It identifies the rapid movement of the tip in the GHz range as the key factor for energy transfer, which is made possible by the generation of phonons within the tip or between the tip and the substrate. The results suggest that local surface deformation can cause significant thermally induced movements during macroscopic friction. ", "entities": [ { "name": "contact delocalization", "entity_id": "contact_delocalization", "entity_type": "concept", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "spatial_extent": "can be complete at any position of cantilever in specific cases", "implication": "requires reconsideration of lateral force amplitude, slip times, and thermal noise interpretation in FFM" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "occurs_in", "target": "FFM measurements", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "visualized_in", "target": "Fig. 2", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "tip apex rapid motion", "entity_id": "tip_apex_rapid_motion", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "characteristic_frequency": "GHz range", "role": "key element for energy dissipation", "model_entity_type": "physical_process" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "relaxes_via", "target": "damping of intratip vibrations", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null }, { "predicate": "relaxes_via", "target": "damping of apex motion with respect to substrate", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "damping of intratip vibrations", "entity_id": "damping_of_intratip_vibrations", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "byproduct": "creation of phonons inside the tip", "model_entity_type": "mechanism" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "relaxes", "target": "tip apex rapid motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "damping of apex motion with respect to substrate", "entity_id": "damping_of_apex_motion_with_respect_to_substrate", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "byproduct": "creation of phonons in substrate and tip", "model_entity_type": "mechanism" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "relaxes", "target": "tip apex rapid motion", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "macroscopic sliding", "entity_id": "macroscopic_sliding", "entity_type": "other", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "potential_dynamics": "more thermally driven dynamics due to local compliance of contacting surfaces", "model_entity_type": "physical_process" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "involves", "target": "asperities", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Fig. 1 simulation parameters", "entity_id": "fig_1_simulation_parameters", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "tip_mass": "10^-20 kg", "source_of_other_parameters": "Ref. [9]", "corrugation_values_eV": "1.2, 1.0, 0.9, 0.7, 0.52, 0.48, 0.43, 0.42", "specific_case_j": "thermal noise switched off (η n = 0)" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "illustrates", "target": "atomic stick-slip and continuous sliding", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] }, { "name": "Fig. 2 simulation parameters", "entity_id": "fig_2_simulation_parameters", "entity_type": "measurement", "aliases": [], "attributes": { "corrugation_values_eV": "0.52, 0.48, 0.44", "variables_plotted": "effective tip-surface interaction and mean surface force versus cantilever position" }, "relationships": [ { "predicate": "shows_effects_of", "target": "contact delocalization", "attributes": {}, "target_id": null } ] } ], "source": { "chunk_index": 6, "start_word": 2866, "end_word": 3254, "word_count": 388, "sha256": "370f10e1689b59f0611853922a8207ea8260adb6f38bed183de61cffee25718e", "sentence_minhash": [ 181103902342795345, 1306423125707224, 61896554882702054, 159448631219318875, 50154285776315358, 62667647458868521, 175774020269814206, 50347065011191293, 64333332902950267, 92715222163426349, 59581572940983686, 127332288920535677, 164575269931903557, 14638101201935915, 423009623579688101, 91498461405850096 ] }, "extraction_warnings": [ "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_process' for 'tip apex rapid motion'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'mechanism' for 'damping of intratip vibrations'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'mechanism' for 'damping of apex motion with respect to substrate'", "normalized unsupported entity type 'physical_process' for 'macroscopic sliding'" ] } ], "canonical_entities": [] }, "chunks_expected": 7, "chunks_generated": 7, "failed_chunks": [], "repair": { "accepted_windows": 4, "rolled_back": false, "original_context_sha256": "5347b9ec80b67303f5f05548e33728d9a1c5fb36cd495aec1266f6555e1fa880", "final_context_sha256": "d5dd5da57eaba167a3d19de8016e1580a14cb7428723a4056c1a153ae04bc334", "critical_values": { "passed": true, "checks": { "numbers": true, "quantities": true, "formulas": true, "mathematical_variables": true, "operators": true }, "before": { "numbers": [ "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "12", "9", "9", "2", "1", "2", "1", "1", "9", "1E+1", "1", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "1E+1", "9", "0.66", "62", "25", "3E+2", "5.5", "1E+1", "-11", "3", "2", "9", "1", "2", "2", "5E+8", "1E+1", "-18", "9", "3", "14", "1E+1", "-18", "7", "9", "1E+1", "1", "3", "1E+1", "2", "1", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "1.2", "1", "0.9", "0.7", "0.52", "0.48", "0.43", "0.42", "0", "2", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44" ], "quantities": [ [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "0.66", "nm" ], [ "62", "N/m" ], [ "25", "nm/s" ], [ "3E+2", "K" ], [ "-11", "kg" ], [ "3", "N/m" ], [ "5E+8", "Hz" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ] ], "formulas": [ "1-i", "1E+1^-11", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "2-a", "3-d", "K(X-Vt)", "N/m", "N/m", "N/m", "X-x", "X=a", "a/2", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "cos(2πx/a)", "exp(-Uij/kBT)", "k(X-x)", "n=0", "n=0.5", "n=η", "p_1+x_2", "s=U", "t-t", "x(X)", "γ<1", "γ>1", "γ>1", "δ(t-t')", "η=5", "ξ(t')", "ξ(t)" ], "mathematical_variables": [ "F_s", "F_s", "U_eff", "c_case_j", "c_frequency", "d_at", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_motion", "d_position", "e_T", "e_conditions", "e_constant_a", "e_in_two_well_regime", "e_in_two_well_regime", "e_of_cantilever_behavior", "e_of_other_parameters", "e_parameter", "e_reduction_factor", "e_reference", "e_result_stability", "e_well_condition", "e_well_condition", "g_parameter", "j_definition", "l_data", "l_dynamics", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_equivalent", "l_extent", "l_model", "l_observation", "l_parameter", "l_parameter", "l_parameter", "l_process", "l_process", "l_range", "l_state", "l_variable", "m_condition", "m_force_normalization", "m_type", "n_behavior", "n_condition", "n_event", "n_explained_by", "n_for_delocalization", "n_for_multiple_wells", "n_jump_rate", "n_mechanism", "n_method", "n_parameter_condition", "n_parameter_status", "n_position_formula", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_to_experiment", "n_values_eV", "n_values_eV", "n_velocity_V", "p_1", "p_2", "p_mass", "p_mass_estimate", "p_probability", "p_rate", "p_rate_condition", "p_rate_consequence", "p_reflects", "r_behavior", "r_bound", "r_bound", "r_estimate", "r_height_comparison", "r_in_two_well_interval", "r_mass_M", "r_mass_range", "r_range", "r_set", "r_slip_timescale", "r_stiffness_K", "s_1", "s_2", "s_access_to", "s_between", "s_damping_coefficient", "s_determined_by", "s_discontinuities_at", "s_effects_of", "s_gradual_change_in", "s_in", "s_interaction", "s_motion_of", "s_plotted", "s_ratio", "s_regime_transition", "s_slip_via", "s_to", "s_tracking_of", "s_via", "s_via", "s_with", "s_with", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_of", "t_on_lateral_force", "t_on_slip_duration", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "u_c", "x_1", "x_2", "x_behavior", "y_attributed_fine_structure_to", "y_attributed_to", "y_cause", "y_contain", "y_encountered_in", "y_to_mass", "γ", "γ", "γ", "γ", "δ", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ξ", "ξ", "ξ", "π", "π" ], "operators": [ "<", "<", "=", ">", ">", "=", "=", "=", "=", "√", "=", "<", "=", "=", "=", "=", "<", "=" ] }, "after": { "numbers": [ "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "12", "9", "9", "2", "1", "2", "1", "1", "9", "1E+1", "1", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "1E+1", "9", "0.66", "62", "25", "3E+2", "5.5", "1E+1", "-11", "3", "2", "9", "1", "2", "2", "5E+8", "1E+1", "-18", "9", "3", "14", "1E+1", "-18", "7", "9", "1E+1", "1", "3", "1E+1", "2", "1", "1E+1", "-2E+1", "9", "1.2", "1", "0.9", "0.7", "0.52", "0.48", "0.43", "0.42", "0", "2", "0.52", "0.48", "0.44" ], "quantities": [ [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ], [ "0.66", "nm" ], [ "62", "N/m" ], [ "25", "nm/s" ], [ "3E+2", "K" ], [ "-11", "kg" ], [ "3", "N/m" ], [ "5E+8", "Hz" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-18", "kg" ], [ "-2E+1", "kg" ] ], "formulas": [ "1-i", "1E+1^-11", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-18", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "1E+1^-2E+1", "2-a", "3-d", "K(X-Vt)", "N/m", "N/m", "N/m", "X-x", "X=a", "a/2", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "chemical:U0", "cos(2πx/a)", "exp(-Uij/kBT)", "k(X-x)", "n=0", "n=0.5", "n=η", "p_1+x_2", "s=U", "t-t", "x(X)", "γ<1", "γ>1", "γ>1", "δ(t-t')", "η=5", "ξ(t')", "ξ(t)" ], "mathematical_variables": [ "F_s", "F_s", "U_eff", "c_case_j", "c_frequency", "d_at", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_by", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_in", "d_motion", "d_position", "e_T", "e_conditions", "e_constant_a", "e_in_two_well_regime", "e_in_two_well_regime", "e_of_cantilever_behavior", "e_of_other_parameters", "e_parameter", "e_reduction_factor", "e_reference", "e_result_stability", "e_well_condition", "e_well_condition", "g_parameter", "j_definition", "l_data", "l_dynamics", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_entity_type", "l_equivalent", "l_extent", "l_model", "l_observation", "l_parameter", "l_parameter", "l_parameter", "l_process", "l_process", "l_range", "l_state", "l_variable", "m_condition", "m_force_normalization", "m_type", "n_behavior", "n_condition", "n_event", "n_explained_by", "n_for_delocalization", "n_for_multiple_wells", "n_jump_rate", "n_mechanism", "n_method", "n_parameter_condition", "n_parameter_status", "n_position_formula", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_regime", "n_to_experiment", "n_values_eV", "n_values_eV", "n_velocity_V", "p_1", "p_2", "p_mass", "p_mass_estimate", "p_probability", "p_rate", "p_rate_condition", "p_rate_consequence", "p_reflects", "r_behavior", "r_bound", "r_bound", "r_estimate", "r_height_comparison", "r_in_two_well_interval", "r_mass_M", "r_mass_range", "r_range", "r_set", "r_slip_timescale", "r_stiffness_K", "s_1", "s_2", "s_access_to", "s_between", "s_damping_coefficient", "s_determined_by", "s_discontinuities_at", "s_effects_of", "s_gradual_change_in", "s_in", "s_interaction", "s_motion_of", "s_plotted", "s_ratio", "s_regime_transition", "s_slip_via", "s_to", "s_tracking_of", "s_via", "s_via", "s_with", "s_with", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_id", "t_of", "t_on_lateral_force", "t_on_slip_duration", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "t_summary", "u_c", "x_1", "x_2", "x_behavior", "y_attributed_fine_structure_to", "y_attributed_to", "y_cause", "y_contain", "y_encountered_in", "y_to_mass", "γ", "γ", "γ", "γ", "δ", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "η", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ν", "ξ", "ξ", "ξ", "π", "π" ], "operators": [ "<", "<", "=", ">", ">", "=", "=", "=", "=", "√", "=", "<", "=", "=", "=", "=", "<", "=" ] }, "numeric_content_present": true, "formula_content_present": true, "exact_text_unchanged": false, "interpretation": "Conservative preservation filter; changed signatures require review and can include harmless reordering or equivalent unit/algebra conversions" } }, "condition": "qwen_ku500_bt", "source_metadata": { "title": "Evidence for contact delocalization in atomic scale friction", "authors": [ "D Abel", "S Yu Krylov", "J W M Frenken" ], "doi": "10.48550/arxiv.0707.3072", "year": "", "openalex_id": "https://openalex.org/W6966472410", "origin": "Existing disjoint 20-paper benchmark cohort", "metadata_added_for_attribution_only": true, "metadata_not_used_to_change_QA_context": true } }